Skip to main content

Cosa Nuestra

Image may contain Art Painting Photography Adult Person Wedding Face Head Portrait Clothing and Hat

6.8

  • Genre:

    Pop/R&B / Rap

  • Label:

    Sony Music Latin

  • Reviewed:

    November 25, 2024

Drawing from his Nuyorican roots and the salsa romántica greats, El Zorro makes a bid for the canon with mixed results.

To really, deeply understand Rauw Alejandro’s new album, it’s key to brush up on the sensuality, palatability, and enduring popularity of salsa romántica. The softer Latin Pop-adjacent version of what some call “salsa gorda”—which predominated in the ’70s, focused on instrumental improvisation, and was notably more political than its counterpart—focuses on big themes: love, sex, parties. Years later, reggaeton, and its top-charting artists, would follow a similar trajectory.

After an immersive jaunt to the future in cyberpunk-coded Saturno, the Puerto Rican playboy places his feet back on terra firma. Named for a ’69 Fania classic by salsa Neoyorquina greats Willie Colón and Héctor Lavoe, Cosa Nuestra clocks in at just over an hour where Alejandro pays conceptual homage to salsa with a grandiose audiovisual proposal. El Gran Combo de Rauw Alejandro is in full force in the title track, introducing the record with a recreation of genre cornerstone “Qué Lío.” Complete with congas, piano, and the hum of upright bass, it’s an ambitious invocation that sets you up for something refreshingly different.

The tragedy of Cosa Nuestra is not that it’s a false promise, but that it’s inconsistent. For every moment Rauw delivers mature artistry, there’s a throwaway. The neo-merengue of “Mil Mujeres” grows until it explodes into breakbeat. Bad Bunny collab “Que Pasaría…” is fun, but leaves you wondering what would have happened if they tried to make something more than chart reggaeton. “Déjame Entrar,” whose accompanying video is one of Rauw’s most luxe, seduces over Mag’s slinky production as it moves between slow percussion, booming dembow, and fast guitar. The other singles, “Touching the Sky” and “Pasaporte,” are noxiously anodyne pop.It’s almost surprising to see Alejandro play it so squeaky-clean knowing he can push the mainstream forward if he wanted to.

The best moments on Cosa Nuestra channel the musical giants from Borinkén and beyond. Those of us who were gagged at his candlelit rendition of Laura Pausini’s 1994 smash “Se Fue” at last year’s Latin Grammys will be pleased to see it here, complete with soaring electric guitar. Alexis y Fido-assisted “Baja Pa’ Aca’” gives a masterclass in smutty harpsichord-driven perreo Ivy Queen herself would throw it back to. With Cosa Nuestra’s whole thing being bringing the past to the present, it raises the question: Where the hell is the salsa?

Aside from a conga or timbales here and there, the classic genre is sadly relegated to an aesthetic motif. What could have been a powerful moment of reinvention, experimentation, and reverence comes off as simple ornamentation. The only moment Rauw wholeheartedly gets into it is a cover of Frankie Ruiz’s salsa romántica classic “Tú Con Él,” a fan-favorite since he played it at Global Citizen Festival. He sounds great and the tribute works, but the effect is the same as Rihanna’s Tame Impala karaoke on ANTI.

The album purports to do one thing and then does another because of how it’s built. Timbaland had a hand on the James Brown-sampling closer “SEXXXMACHINE.” Pharrell’s touch on “Committed,” a steamy trap-bolero where Rauw sings in English, is palpable. Otherwise, most of the production on Cosa Nuestra is courtesy of Rauw and his close-knit team. Nothing wrong with that, but it would have added so much to invite a salsa OG to the mixing board if that was the goal; some of them are very much alive and kicking. If you’re going to propose salsa, don’t just dip your chips in the sauce.

Alejandro has unquestionable taste, ability, and sex appeal—but does that make an original? A success, certainly, but invoking the innovators without innovating doesn’t pave the road to longevity he makes a bid for. With the amount of intriguing cross-genre moments and club bangers here overlooked to uplift safer pop singles, Cosa Nuestra will satiate the masses and the stans. The salsa purists will cringe. Whoever came looking for something truly new—or, God forbid, cohesive—will leave only slightly buzzed, wondering why the espresso martinis and Uber home were so damn expensive.

All products featured on Pitchfork are independently selected by our editors. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission.